(631) 969-4061

The Penny Pub

Bay Shore, NY

Cold Beer, Late Night Food, Good Company

We have been bringing people together for over 100 years, and look forward to doing so in the years ahead.

Read Full History

Kitchen Open Late

Until 3am

Order for Pick Up
View Menu

Can’t make it to the pub?
Get it delivered.

FREE DELIVERY HERE!

Upcoming Events

Have a holly jolly Christmas Eve by joining us for a special Christmas Bingo starting at 8 pm!

Christmas Bingo

Christmas Bingo

December 24, 2024

Starts at 8:00 pm

More Information
Join us for our Customer Appreciation Holiday Event on Wednesday, December 18th - Friday, December 20th! Bring a $10 donation and get 25% off your bar tab from 4 pm - 8 pm. All proceeds will go to the Brookside Children's Medical Center for terminally ill children & teens!

Customer Appreciation Holiday Event

Customer Appreciation Holiday Event

December 18, 2024

Starts at 4:00 pm

More Information
View All Events

Always at the penny

Monday through Friday

3-8pm

OTB & Quickdraw

Start Your Own Team!

Call or stop in for details

connect with us

Let Us Cater Your Next Event.

Perfect for holiday parties, work events, game nights & more. Pick up or delivery available.
Contact us